During Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s visit to West Bengal, a scene of him eating jhalmuri has now turned into a major political issue. The sharpest reaction in this matter has come from West Bengal Chief Minister and Trinamool Congress leader Mamata Banerjee, who described the entire incident as “pre-planned” and “scripted,” raising serious questions.
Mamata Banerjee stated that the presence of cameras, microphones, and complete arrangements in advance clearly indicates that this was not a spontaneous घटना. She also said that in the presence of the Special Protection Group, such an activity does not seem possible without prior preparation. According to her, the entire scene appears to be a “publicity stunt.”
Questions over security protocol
Mamata Banerjee expressed serious concerns regarding security protocol. She said that during the Prime Minister’s visit, the entire area is usually placed under tight security, shops are closed, and barricading is done along the roads. In such a situation, a shop remaining open and such an activity taking place raises many questions.
Jansuraj Party also raises strong concerns
Reactions from other political parties have also started emerging. Jansuraj Party spokesperson Tariq Anwar Champarani strongly reacted, saying: “How did a jhalmuri shop remain open during the Prime Minister’s visit? How did such a major security lapse occur? The officer responsible for the Prime Minister’s security should be immediately dismissed and arrested.”
He further added that when the President or Prime Minister visits any area or conducts a roadshow, police forces are deployed, and roadsides are secured using barricades such as pipes or bamboo. Shops along the roads are temporarily closed as part of protocol. He questioned whether the shop was open on its own or deliberately kept open. This statement has further intensified the political angle of the controversy.
Debate over the role of SPG
The role of the Special Protection Group is also under debate. Security experts say that the primary responsibility of this force is to ensure the Prime Minister’s safety, not to organize events. However, they also acknowledge that security protocols in any public appearance of the Prime Minister are extremely strict.
Viral claims and facts
Various claims are circulating on social media regarding the incident. Some are calling it a security lapse, while others are describing it as part of political promotion. However, no official agency or credible source has yet confirmed whether there was any security breach or if the event was entirely pre-planned.
Political analysis: From a simple scene to a major controversy
Political analysts believe that a simple street food moment like jhalmuri has now turned into a major political symbol. While some describe it as public outreach, the opposition portrays it as “image building” and a “scripted event.”
As of now, neither the central government nor the Special Protection Group has issued any official response. However, it is clear that the “jhalmuri controversy” has added fresh heat to the politics of West Bengal.
